• I want to consult a lawyer in the Yaizu, Yoshida, Makinohara, Fujieda, or Omaezaki area
• My vehicle was totaled in a traffic accident, and I need to replace it
• The insurance company only offered the market value of the vehicle, and I want to know if I can also claim replacement costs
• I want to know if I can claim registration fees, parking space certificate fees, and vehicle disposal fees from the at-fault party
• I want to verify whether the property damage settlement offered by the insurance company is fair

Are you troubled by issues like these in Yaizu, Makinohara, Omaezaki, Fujieda, Shimada, Yoshida Town, or surrounding areas?
Yaizu Sogo Law Office offers a free initial legal consultation regarding traffic accident concerns. There is no obligation to retain our services after the initial consultation. We are also available on weekday evenings and Saturdays. Please feel free to contact us by phone or email.

When a vehicle is totaled in a traffic accident, the market value of the vehicle is not the only compensable damage

When a vehicle is severely damaged in a traffic accident and cannot be repaired, or when the repair costs exceed the value of the vehicle, the issue of a "total loss" arises.

In such cases, the at-fault party's insurance company may make an offer such as:

"The market value of the accident vehicle is 800,000 yen, so we will pay 800,000 yen."

However, if the accident had not occurred, the victim could have continued driving the same vehicle.

If the victim is forced to replace the vehicle due to the accident, in addition to the cost of the vehicle itself, various additional expenses arise, such as:

• Registration procedure fees
• Parking space certificate fees
• Vehicle disposal fees
• Fees for delegating procedures to the dealership

These costs, which become necessary due to the vehicle replacement caused by the accident, are generally referred to as "replacement incidental costs" (kaikae shohiyo).

When a vehicle is totaled in a traffic accident, it may be possible to claim not only the market value of the vehicle but also replacement incidental costs that are found to have a reasonable causal relationship with the accident.

In what situations do replacement incidental costs become an issue?

The typical case where replacement incidental costs become an issue is when a vehicle is deemed a "total loss."

There are broadly two types of total loss:

• Physical total loss
• Economic total loss

A physical total loss means the damage from the accident is so severe that the vehicle cannot be technically repaired.

An economic total loss, on the other hand, means that while the vehicle can technically be repaired, the repair costs exceed the market value of the vehicle, making replacement more economically rational than repair.

For example:

• Repair cost: 1,000,000 yen
• Vehicle market value: 700,000 yen

However, when determining whether a vehicle is an economic total loss, one does not simply compare the repair cost with the vehicle's market value.

In principle, the comparison is between "repair cost" and "vehicle market value + replacement incidental costs."

Therefore, when an insurance company states:

"The repair cost exceeds the market value, so it is a total loss,"

it is important to verify whether replacement incidental costs have been included in the comparison.

What types of costs qualify as "replacement incidental costs"?

Whether a cost qualifies as a replacement incidental cost is determined based on the following criterion:

"Was the cost ordinarily necessary because the vehicle had to be replaced due to the accident?"

The following are representative examples of such costs:

(1) Statutory fees required for registration

When replacing a vehicle, registration procedures are required for the new vehicle.

The statutory registration fees incurred in this process may be recognized as damages, as they are costs necessitated by the replacement.

The rationale is that these expenses would not have been incurred had the accident not occurred, and therefore they are evaluated as damages caused by the accident.

(2) Registration procedure agency fees

When actually purchasing a vehicle, it is common practice to have the dealership handle the registration procedures rather than doing it oneself.

Therefore, registration procedure agency fees paid to the dealership may also be recognized as replacement incidental costs, provided the amount is within a reasonable range.

"These costs are not denied simply because they could have been avoided by handling the procedures personally."

There are court precedents that have recognized such costs as damages with a reasonable causal relationship to the accident, given that it is standard practice in the automobile purchase process to delegate these procedures to the dealership.

(3) Costs required for parking space certificate

When purchasing a new vehicle, it may be necessary to obtain a parking space certificate (shako shomeisho).

The statutory fees required to obtain a parking space certificate may also be claimable as costs necessary for the replacement.

(4) Parking space certificate procedure agency fees

The parking space certificate procedure may also be delegated to a dealership or administrative scrivener.

Such agency fees may also be recognized as damages, provided the amount is within a reasonable range.

(5) Costs required for vehicle disposal procedures

Costs required to dispose of the totaled accident vehicle are also at issue.

For example:

• Deregistration-related fees
• Statutory fees for vehicle disposal procedures
• Reasonable costs necessary for scrapping and dismantling

If the vehicle would not have needed to be disposed of had the accident not occurred, such costs may be claimable as damages to the extent that a relationship with the accident is recognized.

(6) Delivery fees

Delivery fees charged by the dealership when purchasing a new vehicle may also be recognized as replacement incidental costs within a reasonable range, according to court precedents.

However, the full amount is not automatically recognized simply because the item is labeled as a "delivery fee."

It is necessary to verify what services the fee covers and whether the amount is reasonable.

What about taxes such as the environmental performance levy?

Taxes may be incurred when acquiring a vehicle.

Currently, when acquiring an automobile, taxes such as the automobile tax environmental performance levy (kankyo seino wari) may be imposed.

Under the former system, the "automobile acquisition tax" was at issue, but the system has since been revised. When a vehicle must be replaced due to an accident and a tax obligation arises from the acquisition of a new vehicle, whether that tax qualifies as accident-related damages becomes an issue.

In prior judicial practice, there are cases where the acquisition tax ordinarily required to purchase a used vehicle comparable to the accident vehicle was recognized as damages.

Under the current environmental performance levy system as well, it is necessary to evaluate on a case-by-case basis whether the levy qualifies as an acquisition-related cost ordinarily necessary for the replacement.

However, the actual amount of the levy varies depending on the vehicle model, acquisition price, and environmental performance.

Therefore, it is important to verify the specific estimates and tax amounts before making a claim.

Is automobile tax a replacement incidental cost?

On the other hand, caution is required regarding automobile tax (jidosha zei).

Automobile tax is essentially a tax imposed on vehicle ownership.

It differs in nature from "costs incurred as a direct result of acquiring a vehicle."

Therefore, the automobile tax for a newly purchased vehicle is generally not automatically recognized as a replacement incidental cost.

Additionally, regarding automobile tax already paid on the accident vehicle, it is necessary to make a case-by-case determination taking into account the availability of tax refund systems and other factors.

"Not all amounts paid to a dealership when replacing a vehicle qualify as damages."

Each item must be verified individually.

Can automobile weight tax be claimed?

Automobile weight tax (jidosha juryo zei) is also frequently at issue as a replacement incidental cost.

The automobile weight tax paid on a newly purchased vehicle is not necessarily recognized as a replacement incidental cost.

On the other hand, regarding the weight tax already paid on the accident vehicle, the issue may arise of whether the unexpired portion of the vehicle inspection period constitutes a loss caused by the accident.

Is compulsory automobile liability insurance (CALI) premium a replacement incidental cost?

The CALI (jibaiseki hoken) premium paid on a newly purchased vehicle is also generally not automatically recognized as a replacement incidental cost.

This is because the CALI premium is a cost necessary for owning and operating a vehicle, which differs in nature from damages caused by the vehicle replacement itself.

Additionally, if there is an unexpired portion of the insurance premium for the accident vehicle, it is necessary to verify the handling under the insurance contract and whether a refund is available.

What about recycling fees?

Recycling fees may become an issue when purchasing an automobile.

There are court precedents in which recycling deposit fees (risaikuru yokitakukin) were recognized as replacement incidental costs.

However, the treatment may differ depending on the recycling fees already deposited for the accident vehicle and the processing at the time of purchasing a new or used vehicle.

Therefore, it is necessary to verify:

• How much was deposited for the accident vehicle
• How much was newly paid for the replacement vehicle
• Whether there is any refund or succession of the deposit

Costs that are unlikely to be recognized as replacement incidental costs

Not all expenses paid when replacing a vehicle can be claimed from the at-fault party.

For example:

• Expensive options added to the new vehicle
• Costs for upgrading the vehicle
• Additional costs due to personal preferences, such as a vanity license plate
• Purchase costs for car navigation systems and other items not present in the pre-accident vehicle
• The price difference resulting from replacing the vehicle with a more expensive model than the pre-accident vehicle

are generally unlikely to be evaluated as damages necessitated by the accident.

The fundamental principle of traffic accident damage compensation is to "restore the victim to the condition that would have existed had the accident not occurred."

The system is not designed to require the at-fault party to bear the cost of acquiring a vehicle or equipment of higher value than what the victim had before the accident.

Can replacement incidental costs not be claimed unless the vehicle is actually replaced?

Some people wonder whether replacement incidental costs can only be claimed if the vehicle is actually replaced.

This issue requires examination depending on the nature of the cost.

For costs such as registration agency fees that arise from an actual replacement, estimates, invoices, and receipts demonstrating the actual expenditure become important.

On the other hand, if the vehicle is objectively a total loss and replacement is necessary, there may be room to evaluate the ordinarily necessary replacement incidental costs as damages.

However, in negotiations with insurance companies, such claims may be contested on the grounds that:

• "The costs have not actually been paid,"
• "The specific amounts are unknown."

Therefore, if you are actually replacing the vehicle, we recommend that you always retain the purchase estimates and cost breakdowns.

How much do replacement incidental costs typically amount to?

Replacement incidental costs are not fixed at a uniform amount.

They vary depending on factors such as:

• Whether the vehicle is a standard-sized or light motor vehicle
• Whether the vehicle is new or used
• The vehicle price
• The registration method
• The dealership's agency fees
• Vehicle disposal costs
• Whether taxes apply

Therefore, it is not possible to calculate that replacement incidental costs are always, for example, 100,000 yen for a vehicle with a market value of 800,000 yen.

The process involves obtaining an actual vehicle purchase estimate and verifying each cost item individually to determine whether it qualifies as accident-related damages.

The insurance company's settlement proposal may not include replacement incidental costs

In property damage settlements for traffic accidents, the at-fault party's insurance company may simply offer "Vehicle market value: 800,000 yen" without any mention of replacement incidental costs.

In such cases, it is important to ask: "Are replacement incidental costs included?"

Additionally, if the insurance company states, "The 800,000 yen includes incidental costs," you should request a breakdown.

• What is the vehicle market value?
• How much are the registration fees?
• How much are the parking space certificate fees?
• How much are the vehicle disposal fees?
• What other costs are being recognized?

It is essential to have these details clarified.

When only a lump-sum amount is presented, it is difficult to notice whether costs that should be recognized have been omitted.

Documents required to claim replacement incidental costs

When claiming replacement incidental costs from the insurance company, it is advisable to prepare the following documents:

• Vehicle inspection certificate of the accident vehicle
• Repair estimate for the accident vehicle
• Appraisal documents for the accident vehicle
• Purchase estimate for the replacement vehicle
• Sales contract
• Breakdown of registration fees
• Breakdown of parking space certificate fees
• Breakdown of vehicle disposal fees
• Invoices and receipts from the dealership
• Documents related to recycling fees

If the estimate only states "incidental costs: lump sum," we recommend requesting a detailed breakdown from the dealership.

In a damage compensation claim, if the purpose of a cost cannot be identified, its necessity cannot be evaluated.

Replacement incidental costs and the determination of economic total loss should be considered together

Another reason replacement incidental costs are important is that they affect the determination of economic total loss itself.

For example:

• Repair cost: 850,000 yen
• Vehicle market value: 750,000 yen

At first glance, since the repair cost is 100,000 yen higher, it appears to be a total loss.

However, if:

• Replacement incidental costs: 120,000 yen

are recognized, then:

In this case, the repair cost of 850,000 yen is less than 870,000 yen.

Therefore, "the repair cost exceeding the vehicle market value does not automatically mean an economic total loss."

When told that the vehicle is an economic total loss, it is essential to verify whether replacement incidental costs have been properly included in the comparison.

When there is contributory negligence, replacement incidental costs are also reduced

In accidents where the victim also bears some fault, replacement incidental costs are, in principle, also subject to comparative negligence reduction.

For example:

• Vehicle market value: 1,000,000 yen
• Replacement incidental costs: 150,000 yen
• Victim's contributory negligence: 20%

In simplified terms, the vehicle damage of 1,150,000 yen would be reduced by 20%.

In other words, replacement incidental costs are not paid at 100% separately.

However, if the negligence ratio itself is disputed, the appropriate negligence ratio must be examined separately from the replacement incidental costs.

Even in 100:0 fault accidents, you may need to negotiate replacement incidental costs yourself

In accidents such as rear-end collisions or collisions with a parked vehicle where the victim bears zero fault, the victim's own insurance company may not be able to negotiate with the at-fault party.

In such cases, the victim must personally negotiate with the at-fault party's insurance company regarding:

• Vehicle market value
• Whether it constitutes an economic total loss
• Replacement incidental costs
• Rental car expenses

and other matters.

Insurance company representatives are experienced in traffic accident damage assessments.

On the other hand, for many victims, a property damage accident is a first-time experience.

• "We can only pay up to the market value,"
• "This cost is not covered,"

When told such things, some victims may accept the settlement as is.

However, the insurance company's offer does not necessarily correspond to the legally recognized amount of damages.

It is important to verify whether replacement incidental costs have been adequately included.

When attorney's fee special clause coverage is available

Attorney's fee special clause (bengoshi hiyo tokuyaku) coverage may also be available for property damage accidents, including those involving replacement incidental costs.

In particular, consulting a lawyer may be beneficial when:

• The accident involves 100:0 fault
• There is a dispute over the vehicle's market value
• There is a dispute over whether it constitutes an economic total loss
• The insurance company refuses to recognize replacement incidental costs
• Rental car expenses are also being disputed

In property-damage-only accidents, attorney's fees may sometimes exceed the amount of damages at issue.

However, if attorney's fee special clause coverage is available, it may be possible to retain a lawyer for negotiations while minimizing the cost burden.

We recommend checking whether attorney's fee special clause coverage is available not only under your own automobile insurance policy but also under family members' policies.

Summary

When a vehicle is totaled in a traffic accident, the damages that can be claimed from the at-fault party are not limited to the vehicle's market value.

If the accident necessitates a vehicle replacement, the following may be claimable as replacement incidental costs:

• Registration fees
• Registration procedure agency fees
• Parking space certificate fees
• Parking space certificate procedure agency fees
• Vehicle disposal fees
• Reasonable delivery fees
• Certain taxes and recycling-related fees

On the other hand, items such as automobile tax, CALI premiums, and automobile weight tax are not necessarily recognized as replacement incidental costs due to the nature of these costs and the availability of refund systems.

Additionally, replacement incidental costs not only increase the compensation amount but also affect the determination of whether a vehicle constitutes an economic total loss.

If the insurance company states:

• "We will only pay up to the vehicle market value,"
• "The repair cost exceeds the market value, so it is a total loss,"

it is important to verify whether replacement incidental costs have been properly taken into account.

Before signing a property damage settlement agreement, we recommend confirming that the vehicle market value, replacement incidental costs, rental car expenses, and other items have been properly calculated.

FAQ

The Initial Legal Consultation for Traffic Accidents at Yaizu Sogo Law Office Is Free of Charge

Yaizu Sogo Law Office provides a free initial legal consultation regarding traffic accidents.

We handle all traffic accident-related legal matters, regardless of severity or whether they involve property damage or personal injury. If you are feeling stressed by dealings with insurance companies, or if you want to know whether the amount offered by your insurance company is fair, please do not hesitate to consult with us.

Yaizu Sogo Law Office is available not only during regular weekday hours but also on weekday evenings and Saturdays. Please contact us by phone or email to schedule a legal consultation.

Are You Troubled by a Traffic Accident?

• Settlement Offers from Insurance Companies Are Almost Always Low
• The Insurance Company Said They Would Cut Off My Medical Expenses
• Dissatisfied with the Fault Ratio
• When and How to Consult a Lawyer About a Traffic Accident
• What Claims Can Be Made in a Personal Injury Accident?
• What Claims Can Be Made in a Property Damage Accident?
• What You Need to Know About Whiplash
• Traffic Accidents and Health Insurance
• Procedures and Steps to Follow After a Traffic Accident
• Fault Proportions Between a Through-Going Vehicle and a Right-Turning Vehicle at an Intersection
• Diminished Value (Loss of Market Value)
• Amount Claimable from the Other Party When Personal Injury Protection Insurance Was Used Prior to the Claim for Damages Against the Other Party
• Free legal consultation is available for traffic accidents
• Filing a Victim's Claim with Compulsory Automobile Liability Insurance (CALI)
• Lost Wages for Salaried Employees (Wage Earners) in Traffic Accidents
• Understanding a Company's Losses When Employees Are Killed or Injured in a Traffic Accident
• Finding the Court with Jurisdiction over Traffic Accident Lawsuits
• Want to Know Whether You Can Offset the Other Party's Damages Against Your Own in the Same Traffic Accident
• The at-fault party refuses to use their voluntary automobile insurance. What should I do?
• I was seriously injured in a traffic accident in June 2017, before the enforcement of the amended Civil Code (April 1, 2020). Three years have passed (but less than five years) since I completed my treatment. Is the statute of limitations still valid?
• How to Identify a Hit-and-Run Driver from a Vehicle License Plate Number
• Methods of Dispute Resolution in Traffic Accidents
• What You Need to Know About Medical Commuting Transportation Expenses
• How to Find the Insurance Company of the At-Fault Driver in a Traffic Accident
• Understanding Workers' Compensation Insurance in Traffic Accidents (Leave Compensation)
• How Much Is the Standard Compensation for a Traffic Accident?
• What Is Residual Disability Grade Certification in Traffic Accidents?
• How Much Compensation Can You Get for Whiplash from a Traffic Accident?
• Benefits of Hiring a Lawyer for Traffic Accidents
• Key Points When Dealing with Insurance Companies After a Traffic Accident
• How to Calculate Lost Income from a Traffic Accident
• The Relationship Between Number of Hospital Visits and Compensation for Pain and Suffering in Traffic Accidents (Key Considerations When Visit Frequency Is Low)
• What Is Maximum Medical Improvement (MMI) After a Traffic Accident?
• How to Use Lawyer Fee Special Coverage for Traffic Accidents?
• How to Handle a Traffic Accident When the At-Fault Driver Has No Insurance
• Damages in Bicycle Accidents
• Claiming Compensation When a Passenger Is Injured in a Traffic Accident
• Do You Have to Pay a Traffic Fine for a Burned-Out Brake Light?
• "I Said I Would Pay the Full Repair Cost" in a Bicycle Accident
• If Repair Costs Exceed Your Car's Market Value After a Traffic Accident, Can You Still Recover the Full Amount?
• Can a Car Proceed if a Pedestrian Yields at a Crosswalk?
• What Are "Replacement Incidental Costs" When a Vehicle Is Totaled in a Traffic Accident?
• What Damages Can Be Claimed When a Family Member Dies in a Traffic Accident?

See all articles on traffic accidents